CHAMBER OF ADVOCATES PLANNING TRAINING FOR CRIMINAL DEFENSE LAWYERS ON THE REPUBLIC OF UZBEKISTAN’S NEW LAW ON PLEA AGREEMENTS
A special Chamber of Advocates subcommittee comprised of the Chamber’s Deputy Chairman, Davron Saidov and Board members, Sergey Irgashev and Tamila Rakhmatullaeva, has been working with the international NGO, Regional Dialogue, on plans to conduct regionally focused online training sessions to provide defense advocates with both a theorical and practical skills-based knowledge of the law on plea agreement that was enacted earlier this year.
Details of the Chamber’s current plans for the first, in a series, of training sessions are presented below after some brief descriptive details about the law on plea agreements and the background of negotiated pleas in the United States, where the practice is generally recognized as having commenced.
Plea Agreements in Certain Criminal Cases in Uzbekistan Are Now Possible
The Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan, Number ZRU-675, became effective on 18 February 2021. The new law was enacted as a supplement to the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC) as a new Chapter 62-1, which provides for the institution of an admission of a guilt agreement in less grave criminal cases. Clauses 8-4 of Part 1 of Article 51, as well as provisions of Chapter 62-1 of the CPC, provides for the mandatory participation of a defense attorney in less grave criminal cases for which an agreement on the admission of guilt of the accused is being or has been concluded with the prosecutor.
The law on plea agreements imposes a fundamentally new role and set of ethical duties and responsibilities on defense lawyers when advising their criminally accused clients regarding: (1) whether to initiate and conclude a plea agreement and (2) if so, the possible consequences of a plea agreement on the accused client. In carrying out their ethical responsibilities, defense advocates have to be aware that the decision to enter plea negotiations as well as the acceptability of any plea agreement are totally decisions that have to been made by the criminally accused client.
Plea Agreements Have Long Been Prevalent in Criminal Cases in the U.S.
The law on plea agreement ushers in aspects of a practice in criminal cases that has been prevalent for some time in the U.S. and many other western countries where the sheer volume of criminal cases is often offered as justification for the practice.
Negotiated plea agreements are agreements between defendants and prosecutors in which defendants agree to plead guilty to some or all the charges against them often in exchange for concessions from the prosecutors. These agreements allow prosecutors and defense lawyers to focus their time and resources on other, often more serious, cases and helps to reduce the number of trials that judges have to conduct. In short, negotiated plea agreements help to conserve valuable resources and often help to conclude criminal proceedings more quickly against the criminally accused.
It is important to mention that most criminal prosecutions in the U.S. conclude with a negotiated plea agreement, often referred to as a plea bargain. The U.S. Department of Justice notes that most criminal cases in the country conclude with a negotiated plea between the prosecutor and the accused.
With most negotiated pleas, prosecutors may agree to reduce the defendant's punishment, often by lowering the number of criminal charges against the defendant. As part of that process, prosecutors in the U.S. may also agree to recommend that a defendant receive a reduced sentence. But it should be noted that many plea agreements require defendants to do more than just plead guilty. For example, prosecutors may often offer favorable plea bargains to defendants who agree to testify or to provide other information to assist in prosecuting charges against other defendants.
It should be noted that the law on plea agreements in Uzbekistan requires the defendant to assist in solving the crime, report information about any property obtained by criminal means, and to compensation for damage caused by the crime. Most important, defense advocates have to advise their criminally accused clients that under current provisions of the CPC any admissions or confessions made by the client as part of the plea agreement negotiations, as well as any other information shared with the investigator and/or prosecutor, even if the plea negotiations do not generate a plea agreement, all such information do not lose their evidentiary value and may likely be used against the accused. The law on plea agreement does not provide for restrictions on the use by prosecutors of such information as evidence.
Ultimately, it is up to the judge to determine whether a plea agreement stands
The judge who has been assigned the criminal case has the ultimate authority to accept or reject a plea agreement. In determining whether to accept or reject a plea agreement, judges in the U.S. and elsewhere, conduct a careful process on the record in open court to ascertain whether the accused has voluntarily and knowingly entered the plea agreement and that he or she comprehends the possible consequences of the plea agreement. In the end, it is up to the court, after careful review, to accept or reject the plea agreement.
Similarly, under Part 1 of Article 586-9 of the CPC, the court has the authority to accept or refuse any plea agreement. If the court refuses the agreement, it may then refer the criminal case back to the prosecutor for further investigation according to general rules or for a revision of the agreement because the court found no grounds for approving the agreement or that the requirements of procedural legislation may have been violated. The court may also reject the agreement because it does not agree with the conditions stipulated in the plea agreement regarding the details of the crime, if the court has reasonable doubts about the guilt of the defendant or because the parties have refused to fully conclude a plea agreement.
The Chamber’s Upcoming Regional Training Sessions on Plea Agreements
Plans are being finalized for an initial online training session that will be conducted over the course of two days with each day’s session being limited to several afternoon hours of training. The first two-day session is tentatively planned for the 28th and 29th of September and will to be conducted in Russian. A subsequent two-day online session will be conducted in Uzbek at a later unscheduled date. Participation in the training sessions will be opened only to defense lawyers. The first part of the training will focus on assisting defense advocates to become familiar with the theoretical basis of the institution of plea negotiations and plea agreements in criminal cases.
The second half of the training will focus on the importance defense practical skills and strategies around advising clients regarding:
• how to best approach a plea negotiation,
• how to fashion a proposed plea agreement,
• the many consequences of plea negotiations and a plea agreement,
• the rights of the accused regarding such agreements, and
• the likely role of the court or judge in reviewing and ruling on any plea negotiation disputes that may arise between the defense and the prosecution.
James B. Eaglin, Legal Specialist, Regional Dialogue